Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney Trilogy sukses menuai banyak pujian baik dari gamer maupun kritikus. Di Steam, game ini mendapat rating “Overwhelmingly Positive” dengan 96% pemain meberikan respon positif.

“I'm honestly quite surprised. I had no idea a game about lawyers could be so well written. In real life, I've heard court cases are one of the most boring things. Not in the Ace Attorney world, however. Bridge to the Turnabout especially. The writers went way too overboard with that one. And as a result, it's the best case I've played in the series to date (as of the writing of this review, I have played the Phoenix Wright Trilogy, Apollo Justice, and am on the last case of Investigations 1).” (AerosTactician / metacritics.com).