Stardew Valley ini sukses mendapatkan hati banyak Gamer dari seluruh penjuru dunia, bahkan di salah satu platform populer Steam, Game ini berhasil mendapatkan Review Positif dengan 98% pemain merasa puas dengan game ini. Bukan hanya Gamer biasa, Stardew Valley berhasil mendapatkan perhatian dari tempat review game terkenal seperti:

“Far more than just a farming game, this one-man labor of love is filled with seemingly endless content and heart.”
5/5 – Giant Bomb

 “The core mechanics and relaxing aesthetic merge so well together that players will sink in to the experience and never want to leave.”
95 – Destructoid 

“Stardew Valley has been the most rich and heartwarming experience I’ve had in a game in years.”
95 – CGMagazine